House search: What are my rights? Answers from a lawyer
.
The police search your home. What are my rights and what should I do?
What is a house search about?
A house search is a compulsory measure under criminal law.
compulsory measure. This means that criminal proceedings have been initiated against you
(
BGE 141 IV 20, Erw.1.1.4). The main purpose of a house search is to secure evidence (
Art. 196 lit. a of the Code of Criminal Procedure) and to secure the
presence of persons in criminal proceedings, in particular the
arrest of accused persons (
Art. 196 lit. b of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Houses,
homes and other premises that are not generally accessible may be searched
if it is suspected that wanted persons are present (
Art.
244 para. 2 lit. a Criminal Procedure Code), traces of the crime or objects or assets to be seized
objects or assets are present (
Art. 244 para. 2 lit. b Code of Criminal Procedure) or criminal offenses
are committed (
Art. 244 para. 2 lit. c Code of Criminal Procedure).
Why was the search ordered?
Either the house search was ordered on the basis of (extensive)
preliminary police investigations or as a result of an incident that had just taken place.
If was ordered on the basis of preliminary police investigations, you must
assume that there is
reasonable suspicion of a criminal offense
exists (
Art. 197 para. 1 lit. c of the Code of Criminal Procedure). You must expect
expect that the public prosecutor's office and the police will have
incriminating information. Since a house search represents a
intrusion into your privacy, it is probably a matter of
a significant criminal offense (
Art. 197 para. 1 lit. d Criminal Procedure Code).
However, a house search can also be ordered if no preliminary police
preliminary police investigations have taken place, but if it is a criminal offense
of which the public prosecutor's office and the police have only just
learned of. In such cases, the public prosecutor's office and
and the police have less information and it is often disputed whether
there was even sufficient suspicion for the house search.
When do house searches take place?
A distinction must be made as to whether the house search is based on
(extensive) preliminary investigations by the police or as a result of a
possible criminal offense that the public prosecutor's office and the police have
have only just learned of. In the former case,
it can be assumed that the public prosecutor's office and the police have incriminating
incriminating information. The public prosecutor's office has
police the order to carry out a house search at your home
carry out a house search (
Art. 312 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). The police officers
usually go to your home at around 06.00 a.m. without flashing blue lights and
sirens and ring the doorbell at your home. The time
of the house search is chosen because you are probably at home,
you are still tired and surprised, you could be taken by surprise, open the
front door of your own accord and let the police in without further ado.
The police will then enter your premises and
carry out the house search. They focus on the items
evidence or persons to be seized in accordance with the public prosecutor's
search order. Depending on the allegation, other
specialists may be on site, such as
dog handlers with search dogs (e.g. on suspicion of
narcotics offenses), forensic technicians to secure evidence
(DNA traces, fingerprints, e.g. in cases of suspected property crime),
Specialists for technical devices (e.g. gambling machines). In
the latter cases, the house searches take place "spontaneously" after the
the possible offense (e.g. violent crimes). This
can be at any time of day or night. The police have
less in-depth knowledge of the facts. It may be that due to
specialists cannot be called out due to the urgency. This
may result in your premises being sealed for the purpose of
purpose of carrying out a second search at a later date.
to be carried out at a later date.
How exactly do searches of apartments, houses or offices work?
The police officers enter your premises, introduce themselves and
present the
house search warrant at the beginning of the search
(
Art.
245 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). If it is an urgent case in which the
the public prosecutor's office and the police have only just learned of a
of a possible criminal offense, a house search can be ordered orally
be ordered (
Art. 241 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). If there is imminent danger,
the police may carry out a house search even without an order from the
public prosecutor's office
(Art. 241 para. 3 Code of Criminal Procedure). The police first check
first check all rooms for persons present. With the persons present
personal details are clarified. The police may
search persons who are stopped, in particular to ensure the safety of
persons (
Art. 241 para. 4 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). At the same time, all
rooms specified in the search warrant are searched (
Art. 241 para. 1 lit. a Code of Criminal Procedure). The
The public prosecutor's office regularly orders the search of all
premises, including garages, vehicles, cellars and attics
and attics. This may be disproportionate in certain circumstances (
Art. 197 para. 1 lit. c Criminal Procedure Code). The police officers
open and search all containers, clothing and documents with gloves and flashlights.
containers, clothing and documents. The procedures are photographed
recorded. Owners of the rooms to be searched who are present must witness the search.
rooms to be searched must be present during the search. If they are absent
If possible, an adult family member or another suitable person
other suitable person (
Art. 245 para. 2 Code of Criminal Procedure). The police may
prohibit persons present from leaving the premises during the search
remove themselves during the search (
Art. 242 para. 2 Code of Criminal Procedure). During the
During the house search, the police will repeatedly ask you questions about
objects, the facts of the case and your person. We advise you,
to make use of your
right to refuse to give evidence (
Art. 158 para. 1 lit. b Criminal Procedure Code). After completion of the
search is completed, you will be given a copy of the execution protocol and a
list of the items seized (
Art. 199 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
What happens if I do not open the front door for the police?
If you do not open the front door of your own accord, the police will try to
persuade you to open the front door, among other things by threatening to
forcing the door open with a pile driver. The
use of force
is expressly permitted by the police as the ultimate means of enforcing
measures (Art. 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). As a rule
However, the door is not forced open immediately, but a locksmith is
instead, a locksmith is called out to try to unlock the door using
attempts to unlock the door. The battering ram can be used if
the locksmith is unable to open the door, e.g. because a house key stuck inside, for example.
What can I do if the police come to my door and want to search my home?
If you are on site, before opening the front door you can
all password-protected cell phones, tablets and computers
switch them off. We assume that you have enough time to do this,
before the police break down your front door. You can leave the
house key so that the locksmith cannot unlock the front door immediately.
cannot unlock the door immediately. After the front door has been opened
ask to see the search warrant. This has the
persons, premises, objects or records to be
records (
Art. 241 para. 1 lit. a of the Code of Criminal Procedure) and the purpose of the
search (
Art. 241 para. 1 lit. b Code of Criminal Procedure). If you are presented with
written order, you know that the police and the public prosecutor's office
the public prosecutor's office have already carried out some preliminary investigations
which have probably established reasonable suspicion. From now on
you must refuse to give evidence and to cooperate,
demand sealing and not disclose any passwords.
House searches must have been ordered as coercive measures by a public prosecutor
have been ordered by a public prosecutor (
Art. 198 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). However, it happens time and again
police officers carry out "house searches" on their own initiative
by ringing the doorbell and asking if they may enter and look around.
enter and have a look around. Such "voluntary"
house searches are controversial and, in our opinion, even
even inadmissible. However, it is also possible that the search warrant
has only been ordered verbally because it is an urgent
case (
Art. 241 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In this case, it is
not yet available in writing. Nevertheless, the police should at least
have a form on which the verbal order has been recorded.
has been recorded. To find out whether the house search was actually ordered by a public prosecutor
by a public prosecutor, you can search for the name of the public prosecutor who
of the public prosecutor who is said to have ordered the house search,
ask. In cases of imminent danger, the police can even carry out searches without an order.
searches without a warrant, but they must inform the public prosecutor's office
must be informed immediately (
Art. 241 para. 3). Such cases practically never occur
never occur, as there is always time to inform the public prosecutor by telephone.
informed by telephone.
During the house search itself, you can clearly indicate to the police
which rooms are occupied by you and which are not occupied by you
occupied by you or are shared by other residents. Make sure
make sure that your statements in this regard are recorded in the
house search are noted. This can also be particularly relevant in relation to
relevant with regard to chance finds (
Art. 243 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In general, we advise you
not to make any further statements to the police, in particular
not to give the police any consent to enter any premises,
no statements regarding questions about the possession of objects
(e.g. clothes, wallets, documents) and not to disclose any
disclose passwords. Although you will be told that it is useless
but always ask for the
sealing of all documents and electronic devices
seized documents and electronic devices (
Art. 248 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). A house search constitutes
constitutes a serious invasion of privacy. Nevertheless
you to behave in a friendly manner towards the police officers.
Do not actively resist (risk of injury). Instead
you can contact a
criminal defense lawyer. If you are not on site
and are informed that a house search is currently taking place, you should
is taking place, you should inform a
defense lawyer and ask them to advise you
advice from them as to whether you should still go on site
or not.
What are the "random finds" all about?
Accidentally discovered traces or objects that are not connected to the
crime to be investigated, but which point to another criminal offense
are seized. The objects are forwarded to the
report to the director of proceedings, who will decide on the
further proceedings (Art. 243 Code of Criminal Procedure). As a rule, the
prosecutor's office after the discovery of traces or objects that are
in connection with another criminal offense, further criminal
opens criminal investigations. It is even obliged to do so (
Art. 7 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). In connection with
questions repeatedly arise about the usability of these finds.
of these finds. We therefore strongly advise you to seek advice in this regard from
a
defense lawyer.
Are searches of the workplace lawful?
Searches of the workplace are generally permissible (
Art. 241 para. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). Nevertheless, they are
particularly annoying because the supervisor and employees become aware
become aware of them. The circumstances must therefore
warrant such searches. Even if the suspicion against you is not subsequently substantiated, such searches can have serious consequences, such as stigmatization
such as stigmatization, loss of trust from superiors,
bullying. In our opinion, such searches are therefore
unlawful in most cases, as they are disproportionate (
Art. 197 para. 1 lit. c Criminal Procedure Code). Also, in the case of
searches at the workplace, further restrictions may apply with regard to the
objects and documents to be searched may also apply, in particular if you
are subject to professional secrecy such as medical confidentiality (
Art. 264 of the Code of Criminal Procedure). We also advise you in the event of
searches at the workplace to have all documents and objects
sealed (
Art. 248 of the Code of Criminal Procedure).
Yes, give us a call.